Blog

Your 'Good' Culture Might Be Broken (And Everyone Knows It But You)

Your culture might not be as "good" as you think. Misaligned values, buried issues, and hidden costs are silently breaking it. This blog uncovers the warning signs of a broken culture, why leaders miss them, and how to rebuild trust and honesty to create a thriving workplace.

Sel Watts - CEO, wattsnextpx
Sel Watts
CEO, wattsnextpx · 
January 14, 2025
Blog post featured image

Want to know the biggest lie in business? "We have a good culture."

I hear it all the time. Usually right before:

  • Another high performer quits
  • Another project fails
  • Another change initiative flops
  • Another engagement survey gets ignored

Here's the uncomfortable truth: Your culture isn't what you believe it is. It's what your people experience every single day.

The Warning Signs Nobody's Talking About

Your culture might be broken if:

  1. The Real Rules
  2. a) Success means playing politics
  3. b) Bad behavior gets rewarded if numbers are good
  4. c) Issues get buried, not solved
  5. d) "That's just how things work here" is the answer to everything
  6. The Silent Signals
  7. a) People nod in meetings but nothing changes
  8. b) Your best people are suspiciously quiet
  9. c) Innovation happens despite the system, not because of it
  10. d) Everyone's waiting for someone else to speak first
  11. The Hidden Costs
  12. a) Simple decisions need five meetings
  13. b) Good ideas die in bureaucracy
  14. c) Projects move at the speed of fear
  15. d) Talent leaves but mediocrity stays

The Leadership Blindspot

Why don't leaders see it? Because broken culture protects itself:

  • Yes-people get promoted
  • Truth-tellers get labeled
  • Problems get cosmetic fixes
  • Feedback gets sanitized

The Real Test

Ask yourself:

  • Would your team tell you if your baby was ugly?
  • Do people bring you problems or hide them?
  • Is "being positive" more important than being honest?
  • Does feedback flow up as easily as it flows down?

The Fix Starts With Truth

  1. Stop:
  2. a) Confusing perks with culture
  3. b) Mistaking silence for agreement
  4. c) Believing your own PR
  5. d) Blaming "a few bad apples"
  6. Start:
  7. a) Rewarding honest feedback
  8. b) Looking for what's not being said
  9. c) Measuring culture like you measure profit
  10. d) Making it safe to speak up

The Bottom Line

Your culture isn't broken because people are negative. It's broken because reality doesn't match the story you're telling.

Time to close the gap.

Because while you're busy believing everything's fine, Your best people are quietly updating their LinkedIn profiles.

What's one cultural truth you need to face this week?

Get insights like these in your inbox
Leadership frameworks and strategies for scaling professional services firms. No spam, just substance.
your@email.com
Subscribe

Browse all